Sunak refuses to answer HS2 questions in series of tough exchanges

Rishi Sunak dodged questions over the way forward for HS2 as he spoke to native radio stations throughout the nation.

The prime minister was repeatedly requested concerning the northern leg of the excessive pace rail line between Birmingham and Manchester.

He was additionally quizzed on whether or not the route would now finish within the west London suburb of Old Oak Common moderately than Euston, as stories proceed to floor that he plans to scrap the subsequent part of the undertaking as a result of hovering prices.

Read extra: PM pushed in collection of dwell interviews – comply with politics dwell

In a tricky change on BBC Radio Manchester, Mr Sunak refused to offer a sure or no reply to the presenter, saying: “I’m not speculating on future things.”

But he hinted at extra assist for the so-called Northern Powerhouse Rail, operating east to west, including: “Having greater frequency, greater capacity and shorter journey times… will make the biggest difference to unlocking the massive potential across the North”.

He additionally appeared to defend the viability of Old Oak Common on BBC Three Counties Radio, saying it had “very strong” connections into the capital.

Please use Chrome browser for a extra accessible video participant


Earlier this week, Rishi Sunak once more refused to substantiate the way forward for HS2’s northern leg.

HS2 was first touted by Labour in 2009, earlier than it was signed off by the Tory Lib Dem coalition authorities. It was designed to attach the South, the Midlands and the North of England with state-of-the-art infrastructure.

If the Manchester leg had been to be axed, it could be the newest watering down of the undertaking, with the japanese leg to Leeds scrapped totally and work between Birmingham and Crewe delayed because of the affect of inflation.

Some estimates have put the overall price at greater than £100bn, whereas the undertaking has been rated “unachievable” by the infrastructure watchdog.

The line has quite a few defenders, from Tory grandees like Lord Heseltine and former chancellor George Osborne, by way of to Labour’s regional mayors, who’ve criticised the federal government for not involving them within the choice over its future.

An announcement on the scrapping of part two and the London terminus had been anticipated this week – nevertheless it has but to floor simply days earlier than the Conservative Party heads to Manchester for its annual convention.

Please use Chrome browser for a extra accessible video participant

Speaking to Sky News, Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham stated individuals within the North had been being ‘handled like second class residents’.

Almost a yr to the day former prime minister Liz Truss confronted a battering on BBC native stations, Mr Sunak carried out the identical pre-conference media spherical, starting with BBC York, which requested him if he had “betrayed” the North over HS2.

“No,” he replied. “I think what people will see… [is] we’re investing record amounts in improving infrastructure but also delivering levelling up. I mean making sure that our town centres and high streets get the investment that they need.

“That’s actually essential and ensuring that, as I say, transport infrastructure is being improved.”

Asked if the northern leg would go forward by BBC West Midlands, the prime minister stated: “There are spades in the ground right now at the moment making sure that we complete the first part of this line from Birmingham to central London, and we are absolutely getting on with that, that is important.”

But he deflected to speak about different types of journey, saying: “We are investing in the transport that they use every day, making sure that the roads that people are using, probably right now as they are driving to work or taking their kids to school, are free of potholes, that the bus services that we have are reliable and frequent.”

Read extra:
What is HS2 and why are components being delayed?
Ex-minister requires inquiry into HS2 as he warns of ‘disastrous’ penalties
Johnson and Cameron criticise transfer to ditch HS2 to Manchester

Mr Sunak’s third outing got here on BBC Manchester and presenter Anna Jameson accused him of “trying to get off” the HS2 matter, asking: “Let’s end this right here right now, tell the people of Greater Manchester, are you scrapping the HS2 line between Birmingham and Manchester?”

The PM replied: “I know there is a lot of speculation on this but we have already got spades in the ground on the first bit of HS2 and what we are doing is getting on with delivering it.”

Pushed on the northern leg, he stated: “It is always right that the government is looking at things to make sure we are doing things in a way that creates value for money.

“But what I might say is HS2 is likely one of the many issues we’re doing to degree up throughout our nation and is likely one of the many issues we’re doing to put money into the north and in transport infrastructure within the north.”

Politics Hub with Sophy Ridge

Politics Hub with Sophy Ridge

Sky News Monday to Thursday at 7pm.
Watch dwell on Sky channel 501, Freeview 233, Virgin 602, the Sky News web site and app or YouTube.

Tap right here for extra

Accusing him of “going off topic”, the presenter requested him to “keep focus”, including: “We are straight talking people in the north it is a yes or a no, are you scrapping the HS2 line between Birmingham and Manchester?”

But once more Mr Sunak insisted he wouldn’t be “speculating on future things”. However, he once more put the deal with the necessity for larger connectivity east to west, hinting it might be on supply if the north to south plan is ditched.

“Connectivity across northern towns and cities is important,” added the prime minister. “I’ve said it for years.

“I do know that that connectivity throughout the Pennines isn’t adequate. And it isn’t simply Liverpool to Manchester, it is all the best way throughout the North. And that’s in all probability the factor that may drive probably the most progress, create probably the most jobs if we will get that proper. And that is why we’re investing in doing that. But we clearly have to do extra.”

English areas unite in calling for solutions on HS2

Mhari Aurora

Political correspondent


The countdown to Conservative occasion convention has begun, and whereas Rishi Sunak would probably wish to be targeted on the allotted themes of every day – the economic system, reducing ready lists and stopping the boats – HS2 seems to be set to derail that agenda.

On a whistle-stop tour of eight regional radio stations this morning, the prime minister was requested concerning the controversial trainline by greater than half of them.

Unsurprisingly the West Midlands and Manchester stations grilled Sunak on the northern leg of the road.

Mr Sunak insisted there have been spades within the floor constructing the road from Birmingham to central London, however as Old Oak Common is located within the London journey zone two, most wouldn’t class that as the center of the town.

The prime minister was accused of going in opposition to the North and betraying its individuals, to which he responded, “I know acutely where the challenges are”, and that he was targeted on investing in transport hyperlinks that folks use each day.

But his justification for specializing in investing in native rail strains and roads making it simpler for individuals to get round would carry jobs, drive progress and make life higher for everybody might be interpreted as considerably ironic, as some would argue HS2 would do precisely that.

The presenter on the Manchester station questioned whether or not Mr Sunak would have the ability to hold on to so-called ‘Red Wall’ seats if he continued the Tory document of damaged guarantees to the North of England.

And after being performed a clip of a leaked recording during which Mr Sunak takes credit score for diverting funds from poor city areas to rural locations, the station accused him of not caring about areas like theirs.

But instantly after that on the Shropshire radio station, the very first query requested was whether or not he was ignoring rural communities.

And on the Three Counties radio station, the presenter performed a recording of 1 man crying as a result of he felt the HS2 improvement had destroyed his city of Wendover.

Indicative of the conflicting instructions during which Mr Sunak is being pulled, the prime minister is below unbelievable stress to not solely decide on the way forward for the highspeed rail hyperlink, however to make the suitable one.

But that call seems to be starkly completely different relying on who you ask.

On BBC Three Counties Radio, Mr Sunak was pushed over the ultimate vacation spot for HS2 within the capital, with presenter Babs Michel asking: “Where is Old Oak Common? Because it appears [it] is closer to Brentford than Trafalgar Square, so what is the point… it doesn’t help us at all.”

But the prime minister appeared to defend it as a wise place to terminate the hyperlink, saying: “Old Oak Common is on the new Elizabeth Line and actually the connections from Old Oak Common to most London destinations, whether that is Heathrow, the City, the West End, Canary Wharf, are actually very strong.

“Obviously it’s a new station that folks will not be aware of, however its connectivity into all these areas may be very robust.”

During the interviews, Mr Sunak was additionally challenged on crumbling concrete, ready occasions for ambulances – and whether or not he needed to purchase Reading Football Club.

Please use Chrome browser for a extra accessible video participant

Speaking to Sky News forward of Mr Sunak’s interviews, transport minister Richard Holden stated it was proper the federal government rigorously considers spending across the high-speed rail undertaking.